Classic Car vs. Daily Driver: Insurance Differences Explained

​Thinking about insuring a classic car?

Learn how classic car insurance differs from standard auto policies—and why it matters for your coverage, value, and cost.

---

​🚗 Not All Cars Are Insured the Same
Whether you’re cruising in a restored '69 Mustang or commuting in your Toyota Camry, insurance matters. But the type of vehicle you drive has a major impact on how your policy works—and classic cars and daily drivers are covered very differently.

If you own (or are considering buying) a classic car, here’s what you need to know about how insurance works, how much it costs, and why standard auto policies aren’t built for collectibles.

🛠️ What Counts as a Classic Car?
Carriers define classic or collectible cars differently, but generally it includes:

• Vehicles at least 20–25 years old
• Well-maintained or restored condition
• Limited annual mileage
• Primarily used for shows, exhibitions, or hobby use—not daily commuting

Some newer specialty or exotic vehicles may also qualify as collectibles under agreed value insurance policies.

Examples of classics:
Chevrolet Bel Air, Ford Mustang (1965–1970), Pontiac GTO, vintage VW Beetles

📋 Key Differences Between Classic Car and Standard Auto Insurance
1. Valuation Method: Agreed Value vs. Actual Cash Value

• Classic car policies use agreed value—you and the insurer agree on the car’s worth upfront. If there’s a total loss, you get that full amount with no depreciation.
• Standard auto policies use actual cash value (ACV)—meaning depreciation applies, and payouts are often less than what it takes to replace your car.

This is one of the biggest differences and why daily auto policies won’t fully protect collector cars.

2. Usage Limits and Mileage Restrictions
Classic car insurance typically includes:

• Low annual mileage limits (2,500–7,500 miles/year)
• No coverage for daily commuting or errands
• Requirement to store the car in a locked garage

Daily driver policies allow unlimited mileage and coverage for commuting, rideshare, or business use.

3. Repair and Restoration Coverage
Classic car policies may allow:

• Choice of specialty repair shops
• Reimbursement for OEM parts or period-correct components
• Limited coverage during restoration (with the right endorsement)

Standard auto policies typically limit parts to what’s "like kind and quality" and don’t include appreciation in value during restoration.

4. Premium Cost Comparison
Despite offering more tailored protection, classic car insurance is often less expensive than daily driver coverage because:

• The vehicle is driven less
• Claims are less frequent
• Owners tend to be highly cautious and low-risk

Premiums vary, but you may pay 30–50% less annually for a classic than for a modern commuter car.

5. Storage & Documentation Requirements
Classic policies often require:

• Proof of secure, indoor storage
• Photos or appraisals of the vehicle
• Secondary insured vehicle for daily driving

Carriers like Hagerty, Safeco (via Hagerty partnership), and American Collectors specialize in this type of underwriting.

🧠 When Should You Consider Classic Car Insurance?
You should explore classic or collector coverage if:

• Your vehicle has significant market or sentimental value
• It’s not used for commuting or business purposes
• You’ve invested time and money into restoration
• You want full control over its valuation and repair options

🚙 When a Standard Auto Policy Makes More Sense
Stick with a standard daily auto policy if:

• You drive the car regularly or daily
• It’s less than 15 years old and depreciating
• It’s used for errands, work, or rideshare
• You need flexible mileage and usage allowances

🧾 Carriers to Know

• Safeco: Offers classic car insurance via its Hagerty partnership
• Progressive: Offers collectible car coverage with agreed value options
• Allstate: Offers standard auto policies with customizable add-ons but no classic-specific package (requires third-party collector insurer)
• Hagerty: Industry leader in agreed-value collector car insurance

🚗 Final Thoughts
Classic cars aren’t just vehicles—they’re investments, passion projects, and family heirlooms. Whether you garage it, show it, or drive it only on Sundays, don’t risk insuring it with the wrong type of policy.

The team at Corin Insurance can help you compare collector car coverage options from trusted carriers and ensure your vehicle gets the specialized protection it deserves.

Disclaimer:
This blog is for informational purposes only and does not guarantee coverage. Always speak with a licensed insurance advisor to review your specific vehicle use and confirm eligibility for classic or collectible car insurance.